The core difference
With UGC, the creator makes videos for your channels. You decide where they run. With influencer marketing, the creator publishes to their own followers. You are paying for their audience and their credibility with it.
Choose UGC when
- You need content for your own account or ads
- You want to test several hooks and angles
- You want to control how and where the video is used
- You are early and want to learn what your customer responds to
Choose influencer marketing when
- You want to reach a new audience
- Trust in a particular person matters for your product
- You are launching something and want a burst of attention
Using both
A common approach is to start with UGC, find the videos that work, and then use the same ideas in a partnership with a creator. A creator who does both, as I do, can carry a concept from one to the other.